Getting quality rest on a comfortable mattress reduces aches and pain and improves your mental and emotional well-being. With so many mattress options, finding the right one can be confusing. Our partners at ConsumerAffairs researched the best mattress stores in Buffalo with mattresses for all sleep types.
Everyone deserves to make thoughtful, informed purchase decisions. The local guides provided on this website are free for consumers. WKBW may receive compensation from our partners. Learn more.
Mattress shopping isn’t as simple as it used to be. Companies are constantly designing new styles of mattresses, and online mattress stores provide more options than ever before. It’s essential to have a good idea of what you’re looking for to avoid being overwhelmed when looking for a new mattress.
As you start your search for a new mattress, here are some things to consider:
Comfort level: Manufacturers usually classify their mattresses as soft, medium-firm or firm. When choosing a comfort level, the goal is to always have your spine in alignment, which may require more or less padding depending on your body shape and whether you sleep on your stomach, back or side.
Pressure relief: Some mattress models provide better pressure relief than others. If you experience pain or pressure points while sleeping, a medium-firm mattress may be right for you.
Price: Mattress prices range from $250 to more than $5,000. Mattresses at the high end of the cost range generally have more features or higher quality construction.
Company features: When evaluating mattress companies, look at warranties, the length of the trial periods and customer reviews before purchasing a mattress. Customer reviews are an excellent way to see how a company’s service and products compare to the competition.
As you start to compare mattresses, it’s essential to know the differences between the multiple styles of construction. While an innerspring mattress is the most traditional choice, many Buffalo residents choose memory foam mattresses or hybrid mattresses for the extra benefits they provide.
Mattress types in Buffalo
Innerspring mattresses use steel inner coils to provide full-body support
$700 - $1,200
Memory foam mattress
Memory foam mattresses are known for its softness, as the material molds to your shape.
Side and back sleepers
$600 - $1,200
Latex mattresses are bouncy and designed to keep your spine in alignment.
$1,500 - $2,500
Hybrid mattresses combine innersprings for support and a latex or memory foam topper.
All sleep types
$1,200 - $2,000
Bed-in-a-box vs. in-store mattresses
Recently, online mattress companies that sell directly to Buffalo residents and ship the mattress to their doors have become more popular. Purchasing a mattress online is a very different experience than buying one in-store, and each has different pros and cons.
When visiting a local Buffalo mattress store, customers can try out different mattress models and have the assistance of a salesperson to choose which is right for them. The mattress is usually delivered on a truck, requiring at least two people to carry it, and the employees set up the mattress on your frame for you.
Online shoppers, on the other hand, are usually drawn to the convenience and cost savings of online mattress companies. These mattresses are vacuum-sealed and delivered in a relatively small box. Once the vacuum seal is broken, the mattress inflates to its full size within hours.
Benefits of online and traditional mattress stores
Online mattress store benefits
Traditional mattress store benefits
Lower prices: Online mattress stores are often able to create an efficient process that allows them to sell mattresses at lower prices.
Convenience: Shopping online allows you to compare the warranties, return policies and other features of businesses from home at any time.
Free trials: Online mattress companies usually offer generous trial periods of 100 days or more.
Wider selection: Brick-and-mortar stores often carry mattresses by multiple brands, letting you see more options in one place.
Ability to test mattresses: Many people are uncomfortable purchasing a mattress without trying it first. Buying from a traditional mattress store lets you feel how comfortable the bed is before buying it.
Mattress delivery and removal: Most physical mattress stores offer mattress setup and can dispose of your old mattress.
What is the average mattress price in Buffalo?
The average price for a queen-size mattress is $1,000, but with so many options, it’s no surprise that the price range for mattresses can vary significantly. At the lower end of the scale, you can find budget mattresses priced as low as $250, while luxury models can cost upwards of $5,000. Size and construction materials play a significant factor in the cost of a mattress.
Keep in mind that there may be additional expenses associated with purchasing a mattress, such as the cost of new bed linens or foundations. If your new mattress needs to be used with a box spring or foundation, expect to spend from $75 to $200 for one. Some mattress types, such as memory foam mattresses, do not require a foundation if you have a platform bed that provides adequate support.
Plan your mattress shopping early to take advantage of inventory clearouts from February to May, when most mattress retailers begin making room for new stock. This schedule doesn’t hold true for online retailers, but many offer ongoing promotions or freebies.
Mattress disposal in Buffalo
Once your comfortable new mattress arrives, you need to properly dispose of your old one. Some companies provide mattress removal free with delivery, while others charge a fee of up to $150 for the service.
When making a final decision on a mattress, there are a few key considerations, including:
Other factors to compare when choosing where to buy a mattress include:
Product warranty: A mattress is a significant purchase, so make sure your new purchase is backed by a warranty against defects. Most companies offer at least a 10-year warranty with their mattresses.
Return policies: It may take a few weeks to become accustomed to a new mattress. Check to see what the trial period is on your mattress and how long you have to return it if you’re not satisfied with your purchase. Mattress companies often offer trial periods of at least 100 days.
Selection: Some mattress companies, especially bed-in-a-box companies, only offer one firmness level. Research multiple companies to be sure you’re getting the style and firmness level you prefer.
While it’s tempting for many Buffalo shoppers to buy the cheapest mattress, doing so is unlikely to give you the best night’s sleep. By researching your purchase and considering the type of mattress that best suits your needs, you can feel more rested in the morning, reduce aches and pains and improve your overall quality of life.
Saatva Mattress sells hybrid mattresses in three different firmness levels. The company provides free delivery and mattress removal, and it sells an adjustable base for customers who want a customized sleep experience. Buffalo reviewers agree that their mattresses are comfortable, and many are impressed with their customer service as well.
Luma Sleep creates luxury mattresses at an affordable price, with a 100-day risk-free trial. Many Buffalo reviewers report that their Luma mattress eases body pain and provides a comfortable night's sleep. Customers can choose from latex or hybrid construction for superior cooling, comfort and durability.
Select Comfort - Sleep Number
Sleep Number pioneered mattresses with personalized comfort levels and offers multiple series for different budgets and sleeping styles. Pair one of their mattresses with a FlexFit base for adjustable feet and head positions. Buffalo residents are impressed with Sleep Number's customer service and the quality of their products.
Using the science of superior comfort, Purple Mattress designed their patented gridded structure for a one-of-a-kind sleeping experience. The multiple levels of pressure-relieving foam create a soft sleeping surface for all types of sleepers. Reviews from Buffalo recommend Purple’s products for their innovative design.
Casper offers online ordering and fast nationwide delivery to make mattress shopping easy. The company has multiple models at different price points and varying levels of foam thickness. The company also sells pillows, bedding and bed frames. Customers in Buffalo appreciate the value of Casper’s products, but some noted issues with the mattresses’ quality.
The Nectar Memory Foam mattress is well-reviewed among back sleepers in particular and noted for its medium-firmness. The company backs their mattresses with a lifetime warranty and a 365-day risk-free trial to ensure the mattress is a good fit for you. Buffalo customers praise the company’s customer service and durable products.
Our partners independently research and analyze the companies mentioned in our guides and work with subject matter experts to add valuable information that helps consumers make smart purchase decisions. Our partners will not include companies on these guides that do not meet specific quality standards. The compensation we receive from our partners may impact how and where companies appear on our site, including the order in which they appear.
Our partners independently research companies, and use editorial discretion to award companies with special recognition (i.e. Best Value) based on their staff’s judgement or subject matter expert’s judgement. Our partners do this to help you identify companies that will meet your specific buying needs, and do not receive compensation for these designations.